- Once bodies or ashes have been buried in consecrated ground, they should not be disturbed except for good and proper reasons. Nevertheless, there seem to be an increasing number of petitions for exhumation, both in this diocese and elsewhere; and in some cases incumbents appear to be advising applicants, possibly for understandable pastoral reasons, that permission will be readily forthcoming.
- The exhumation of a body or of ashes requires a faculty, which will never be granted unless there are special circumstances that justify the making of an exception to the normal rule - that Christian burial in consecrated ground, whether in a churchyard or in a consecrated section of a municipal cemetery, is final.
- Thus, for example, it is not sufficient to show:
- a change of mind on the part of the relatives of the deceased,
- that some or all of those relatives are no longer able conveniently to visit the grave,
- that the spouse or another close relative of the deceased has subsequently been
buried elsewhere, or
- that a surviving spouse or other close relative wishes to be buried (in the future) in the same place as the deceased - but that a further burial at the same location as that which has already taken place is either for some reason now impossible or else considered to be undesirable.
- Any medical reasons relied upon by an applicant would have to be very powerful indeed to create an exception to the normal rule - for example, a serious psychiatric or psychological problem, where medical evidence demonstrates that it is linked to the question or the location of the grave of a person to whom the applicant had a special attachment.
- However, there are two situations in which the prospects of obtaining a faculty are less remote. The first is where it can be shown that a genuine mistake occurred at the time of the burial - such as, that it took place in the wrong plot, or where there was at the time no knowledge that it was taking place in consecrated ground, with its special significance as a place of Christian burial.
- The second possible exception is where exhumation takes place with. a view to re-interment in an existing or proposed family grave. Such multiple use of grave space is to be encouraged, as an expression of family unity and as an economical use of land for burials. It should not, however, be assumed that a faculty will always be granted in such circumstances. A husband and wife should make provision in advance by way of the acquisition of a double gravespace if they wish their bodies to be buried together.
- The passage of time, especially when this runs into years, may make it less likely that a faculty will be granted; although this will not be determinative. And no distinction is to be drawn between a body and cremated remains, except in so far as the processes of decay may affect a coffin more than a casket containing ashes and may also affect the sensibilities of a congregation or neighbours.
- Incumbents faced with such applications should be able to explain the above principles at the earliest opportunity, so that they can give appropriate guidance to applicants - and avoid much subsequent distress on the part of those whose applications are bound to be refused.
Jacqueline L Humphreys
Chancellor of the Diocese of Worcester
August 2021